WEBVTT

1
00:00:01.859 --> 00:00:07.790
<v Graham Cluley>He takes his gun and he sort of shoots the word leek, L-E-E-K.</v>

2
00:00:07.790 --> 00:00:13.721
<v Graham Cluley>I apologise to any English teachers who are listening to this, into a wall as if to prove it really is him.</v>

3
00:00:13.721 --> 00:00:23.500
<v Paul Ducklin>Leek is a legitimate word. I mean, it's a type of onion. What's wrong with that?</v>

4
00:00:23.500 --> 00:00:53.500
<v Graham Cluley>Well, I suppose so.</v>

5
00:00:57.115 --> 00:01:12.114
<v Graham Cluley>It wouldn't</v>

6
00:01:12.114 --> 00:01:27.114
<v Graham Cluley>be so good.</v>

7
00:01:15.257 --> 00:01:25.314
<v Unknown>Smashing Security, episode 482.</v>

8
00:01:25.314 --> 00:01:32.834
<v Paul Ducklin>This hacker leaked GTA 6 and launched their own cryptocurrency with Graham Cluley and</v>

9
00:01:32.834 --> 00:01:40.353
<v Paul Ducklin>special guest Paul Ducklin.</v>

10
00:01:40.353 --> 00:01:46.725
<v Unknown>Hello, hello, and welcome to Smashing Security, episode 482.</v>

11
00:01:46.725 --> 00:01:53.097
<v Unknown>My name's Graham Cluley.</v>

12
00:01:53.097 --> 00:02:05.534
<v Paul Ducklin>And I am Paul Ducklin. Hello, Duck.</v>

13
00:02:05.534 --> 00:02:13.020
<v Graham Cluley>Great to have you back on</v>

14
00:02:13.020 --> 00:02:20.506
<v Graham Cluley>the show again.</v>

15
00:02:20.506 --> 00:02:34.967
<v Paul Ducklin>Thank you, Graham.</v>

16
00:02:34.967 --> 00:02:41.266
<v Graham Cluley>We parachuted you in this week actually, 'cause that person we were intending to come on hasn't managed.</v>

17
00:02:41.266 --> 00:02:47.566
<v Graham Cluley>Not that you are by any means a pale substitute.</v>

18
00:02:47.566 --> 00:02:55.813
<v Paul Ducklin>I'm not pale at all these days.</v>

19
00:02:55.813 --> 00:03:04.061
<v Paul Ducklin>We've had so much sunshine.</v>

20
00:03:04.061 --> 00:03:21.883
<v Graham Cluley>No, that's true.</v>

21
00:03:21.883 --> 00:03:28.036
<v Paul Ducklin>As you can see, I've had a bit too much lately, if those of us</v>

22
00:03:28.036 --> 00:03:34.189
<v Paul Ducklin>who can see me on video.</v>

23
00:03:34.189 --> 00:03:43.382
<v Graham Cluley>Well, it's always great to have you here. Before we kick off, let's thank this week's wonderful sponsors, ThreatLocker, BlackKite, and Vanta. We'll be hearing more about them later on in the podcast.</v>

24
00:03:43.382 --> 00:03:52.574
<v Graham Cluley>This week on Smashing Security. We're not going to be talking about how Iranian hackers managed to shut down a UK power plant.</v>

25
00:03:52.574 --> 00:04:06.901
<v Paul Ducklin>You'll hear no discussion of—</v>

26
00:04:06.901 --> 00:04:16.714
<v Graham Cluley>How a ransomware crook silently ripped off his own gang by posing as a recovery firm and pocketed the victims' payments for himself. And we won't even mention how the Toxic Panda Trojan is quietly taking over Android phones to steal banking PINs and passwords. Now, Duck, what are you going to be talking about this week?</v>

27
00:04:15.800 --> 00:04:25.800
<v Paul Ducklin>I mean, Cyber</v>

28
00:04:16.714 --> 00:04:26.714
<v Paul Ducklin>Well, Graham, if your smart TV</v>

29
00:04:25.800 --> 00:04:35.800
<v Paul Ducklin>Onion wouldn't sound</v>

30
00:04:26.714 --> 00:04:36.714
<v Paul Ducklin>isn't spying on you, what else</v>

31
00:04:35.800 --> 00:04:45.800
<v Paul Ducklin>great, but Cyber Leek—</v>

32
00:04:36.714 --> 00:04:46.714
<v Paul Ducklin>might it be doing behind your back?</v>

33
00:04:40.105 --> 00:04:45.668
<v Unknown Guest>This episode of Smashing Security is supported by ThreatLocker.</v>

34
00:04:45.668 --> 00:04:51.232
<v Unknown Guest>Agentic AI is beginning to change the tempo of cyberattacks.</v>

35
00:04:51.232 --> 00:04:57.293
<v Graham Cluley>That's right.</v>

36
00:04:57.293 --> 00:05:03.355
<v Graham Cluley>We've seen research into autonomous ransomware, adaptive AI worms, and agents chaining tools without waiting for a human operator.</v>

37
00:05:00.319 --> 00:05:15.319
<v Paul Ducklin>It is a pun, Graham,</v>

38
00:05:03.355 --> 00:05:11.875
<v Unknown Guest>Which is all very interesting, just so long as it isn't your</v>

39
00:05:11.875 --> 00:05:20.394
<v Unknown Guest>network they're experimenting on.</v>

40
00:05:15.319 --> 00:05:30.319
<v Paul Ducklin>whether you approve of it or not.</v>

41
00:05:20.394 --> 00:05:29.675
<v Graham Cluley>When enumeration, exploitation, and lateral movement happen at machine speed, relying on somebody to notice an alert and respond quickly begins to look rather optimistic. Well, ThreatLocker puts default deny and least privilege between the agent and its next action. So application allowlisting controls execution, ring-fencing restricts what trusted applications can access or launch, and privileged access management removes unnecessary elevation.</v>

42
00:05:29.675 --> 00:05:35.213
<v Unknown Guest>The attacker may be moving faster, but the controls are already in place. Agentic AI doesn't make established security principles obsolete.</v>

43
00:05:35.213 --> 00:05:40.752
<v Unknown Guest>It makes getting them right considerably more urgent.</v>

44
00:05:40.752 --> 00:05:49.249
<v Graham Cluley>So make sure that you are prepared for machine speed attacks with ThreatLocker. Visit threatlocker.com/smashing today to learn more and schedule your free demo.</v>

45
00:05:49.249 --> 00:05:55.026
<v Unknown Guest>That's threatlocker.com/smashing.</v>

46
00:05:55.026 --> 00:06:00.802
<v Unknown Guest>And thanks to ThreatLocker for supporting the show.</v>

47
00:06:00.802 --> 00:06:06.252
<v Graham Cluley>Now, chums, chums, Grand Theft Auto. It's one of the most successful entertainment products ever made.</v>

48
00:06:06.252 --> 00:06:11.701
<v Graham Cluley>Duck, have you ever played Grand Theft Auto?</v>

49
00:06:11.701 --> 00:06:21.701
<v Paul Ducklin>No, because when I had</v>

50
00:06:21.701 --> 00:06:31.701
<v Paul Ducklin>my own grand theft bicycle</v>

51
00:06:31.701 --> 00:06:41.701
<v Paul Ducklin>from outside my own flat—</v>

52
00:06:46.319 --> 00:07:16.319
<v Graham Cluley>No, no, not a laughing matter.</v>

53
00:07:06.202 --> 00:07:16.218
<v Graham Cluley>I've never played Grand Theft Auto.</v>

54
00:07:16.218 --> 00:07:28.144
<v Paul Ducklin>I've seen it.</v>

55
00:07:28.144 --> 00:07:37.538
<v Graham Cluley>Yes, exactly. I've seen it. I've looked over people's shoulders while they're playing it, and it does seem very impressive. It's a huge, open-world game. It's all about a life of crime. It has earned over $8 billion — billion with a B — since it launched in 2013. It's made more cash than any Hollywood movie. It's still being played by millions of people more than a decade later. And that's really a testament to how much people love this game. And also, I think, it really underlines how desperate people are now, some 13 years later, for a sneak peek of its sequel, which is GTA 6. It is gonna be finally released, they promise, this November. Well, Thursday this week, actually the day that this episode airs at 3:00 PM Eastern time, amongst much hoopla, Netflix will be exclusively premiering a first look of GTA 6's gameplay ahead of its official release. So I think the preview will be up for about 24 hours or something.</v>

56
00:07:37.538 --> 00:07:46.680
<v Paul Ducklin>Will you be able to play it or will you just be able to watch players zooming around?</v>

57
00:07:46.680 --> 00:07:51.860
<v Graham Cluley>I really don't know, 'cause I do believe it is possible these days to play games via Netflix. Maybe younger listeners would be able to educate us as to whether that's possible or not. At the very least, I'm sure there'll be videos to watch of it. And people are very excited about this 'cause it'll be their first chance to see GTA 6.</v>

58
00:07:51.860 --> 00:07:57.038
<v Graham Cluley>No, it won't. No, it won't, because someone has beaten them to it. A hacker or a group, no one's quite sure. A hacker called Cyberleek has started to drop—</v>

59
00:07:52.541 --> 00:08:02.541
<v Graham Cluley>And the tyres are going to be hitting the tarmac as I</v>

60
00:07:57.038 --> 00:08:06.819
<v Paul Ducklin>Cyberleek. I bet that name took months to think up.</v>

61
00:08:02.541 --> 00:08:12.541
<v Graham Cluley>enter the world of Grand Theft Auto 6.</v>

62
00:08:06.819 --> 00:08:12.923
<v Graham Cluley>Well, you may laugh, Duck, at their particular moniker, but they're going to be putting out clips of what is one of the world's most closely guarded pieces of software. So they've been putting out video clips of game characters driving around the streets of Grand Theft Auto.</v>

63
00:08:12.541 --> 00:08:22.541
<v Graham Cluley>All this and much more coming up in this episode of Smashing Security.</v>

64
00:08:12.923 --> 00:08:19.028
<v Graham Cluley>They've been swimming, they've been visiting strip clubs, they've been tasering each other.</v>

65
00:08:19.028 --> 00:08:29.348
<v Unknown Guest>Swimming?</v>

66
00:08:29.348 --> 00:08:46.687
<v Graham Cluley>Yes, you can swim in these games.</v>

67
00:08:35.885 --> 00:09:05.885
<v Graham Cluley>Yes.</v>

68
00:08:46.687 --> 00:08:59.282
<v Paul Ducklin>It's aquatic car.</v>

69
00:08:59.282 --> 00:09:09.282
<v Graham Cluley>Not everything happens in a</v>

70
00:09:09.282 --> 00:09:19.282
<v Graham Cluley>car. You really haven't played</v>

71
00:09:19.282 --> 00:09:29.282
<v Graham Cluley>this, have you?</v>

72
00:09:28.735 --> 00:09:38.692
<v Graham Cluley>You can fly planes and helicopters. You can go down zip wires. You can walk around. You can go into buildings. There's a lot of effing and jeffing as well. There's a lot of very bad language.</v>

73
00:09:38.692 --> 00:09:46.350
<v Paul Ducklin>So how did they get hold of this if it's so</v>

74
00:09:46.350 --> 00:09:54.008
<v Paul Ducklin>$8 billion worth protected?</v>

75
00:09:54.008 --> 00:10:00.398
<v Graham Cluley>Well, we don't know. We don't know how this has happened. Some people have been questioning, well, is it really footage of the game because the game hasn't come out yet? Or is it someone who's taken some other footage which may have leaked out in the past?</v>

76
00:10:00.398 --> 00:10:06.787
<v Graham Cluley>Because there have been other leaks which have come from GTA and Rockstar Games before. At one point, what Cyberleek actually does in this clip which he shows, he shows himself, or rather his in-game character, evading the police. And then he takes his gun and he sort of shoots the word leek, L-E-E-K — I apologise to any English teachers who are listening to this — into a wall as if to prove it really is him playing it.</v>

77
00:10:04.379 --> 00:10:14.379
<v Paul Ducklin>That was enough to convince</v>

78
00:10:06.787 --> 00:10:13.684
<v Paul Ducklin>Leek is a legitimate word. I mean, it's a type of onion.</v>

79
00:10:13.684 --> 00:10:20.581
<v Paul Ducklin>What's wrong with that?</v>

80
00:10:14.379 --> 00:10:24.379
<v Paul Ducklin>me that this is not</v>

81
00:10:20.581 --> 00:10:50.581
<v Graham Cluley>Well, I suppose so.</v>

82
00:10:24.379 --> 00:10:34.379
<v Paul Ducklin>a laughing matter, Graham.</v>

83
00:10:42.562 --> 00:11:12.562
<v Graham Cluley>It wouldn't be so good.</v>

84
00:11:09.980 --> 00:11:15.644
<v Graham Cluley>Okay, that's true. That is true.</v>

85
00:11:13.750 --> 00:11:23.750
<v Paul Ducklin>I mean, it's more than</v>

86
00:11:15.644 --> 00:11:21.306
<v Graham Cluley>Now, this would normally be a story of a hacker breaking into a company and the company, you know, sort of saying, oh, that's terribly embarrassing, and scrambling around to sort of fix the damage afterwards.</v>

87
00:11:21.306 --> 00:11:35.178
<v Paul Ducklin>We take your security seriously, blah, blah, blah.</v>

88
00:11:23.750 --> 00:11:33.750
<v Paul Ducklin>a year ago.</v>

89
00:11:33.750 --> 00:11:43.750
<v Paul Ducklin>I'm almost over it now.</v>

90
00:11:35.178 --> 00:11:41.264
<v Graham Cluley>Exactly that kind of thing. And that's obviously part of the story, but there is more to it because Cyberleeks didn't just want attention.</v>

91
00:11:41.264 --> 00:11:47.349
<v Graham Cluley>It appears that they also wanted cash, but not through extortion, which you would expect, you know, Grand Theft Auto and Rockstar Games wallowing around in cash.</v>

92
00:11:47.349 --> 00:11:54.163
<v Paul Ducklin>Oh, you mean saying Rockstar, pay us money and we'll shut</v>

93
00:11:54.163 --> 00:12:00.976
<v Paul Ducklin>the whole leak down?</v>

94
00:12:00.976 --> 00:12:10.370
<v Graham Cluley>There's that. But what they have done in this particular case is the hacker has launched their own cryptocurrency, which they have dubbed rather unimaginatively—</v>

95
00:12:10.370 --> 00:12:19.187
<v Paul Ducklin>Let me guess.</v>

96
00:12:19.187 --> 00:12:29.687
<v Graham Cluley>Cyberleek.</v>

97
00:12:29.687 --> 00:12:45.059
<v Unknown Guest>Yes. Oh.</v>

98
00:12:45.059 --> 00:12:51.825
<v Graham Cluley>Yes. Sorry, I ruined your fun. So they created their own cryptocurrency called Cyberleek, and they announced that every time someone buys or sells some Cyberleek cryptocurrency, obviously Cyberleek, the hacker, they're gonna get a cut of the trading fees because of how they've set it up, right?</v>

99
00:12:51.825 --> 00:12:58.590
<v Graham Cluley>So they've set it up on Solana, I think is where they've got it. And to incentivise you to buy and sell Cyberleek cryptocurrency, they've said that if the market capital of the Cyberleeks cryptocurrency hits $3 million, they will release a clip from inside the Grand Theft Auto strip club.</v>

100
00:12:58.590 --> 00:13:07.739
<v Unknown Guest>Oh dear.</v>

101
00:13:02.643 --> 00:13:32.643
<v Paul Ducklin>I said I hadn't.</v>

102
00:13:07.739 --> 00:13:12.905
<v Graham Cluley>Sure enough, within 24 hours, the market capital did hit $3 million and the clip was released from that part of the game. And this was all to the hackers' financial advantage because they're getting some of the money.</v>

103
00:13:12.905 --> 00:13:18.072
<v Graham Cluley>They're not only getting a cut of the trading fees, but apparently they also have something like 27% of all of the Cyberleek cryptocurrency themselves anyway. So if the price of Cyberleek, the crypto, goes up, that's more money in their pocket.</v>

104
00:13:18.072 --> 00:13:24.451
<v Paul Ducklin>So how did they prove that it really is a leak from the game and not just some blurry AI-generated variant</v>

105
00:13:24.451 --> 00:13:30.828
<v Paul Ducklin>of something that was in a previous issue?</v>

106
00:13:30.828 --> 00:13:40.828
<v Graham Cluley>It's difficult to prove when no one has really seen it. But what has happened is Rockstar Games have launched DMCA takedown requests.</v>

107
00:13:40.828 --> 00:13:50.828
<v Graham Cluley>They're subpoenaing, if I could say that, subpoenaing. Am I saying that correctly?</v>

108
00:13:47.802 --> 00:14:02.802
<v Paul Ducklin>I mean, CyberOnion</v>

109
00:13:50.828 --> 00:14:00.828
<v Graham Cluley>It's too difficult for me.</v>

110
00:13:53.013 --> 00:14:03.013
<v Paul Ducklin>Subpoena means under</v>

111
00:14:02.802 --> 00:14:17.802
<v Paul Ducklin>wouldn't sound great, but Cyberleek—</v>

112
00:14:03.013 --> 00:14:13.013
<v Paul Ducklin>penalty if you</v>

113
00:14:13.013 --> 00:14:23.013
<v Paul Ducklin>don't do it, literally.</v>

114
00:14:15.345 --> 00:14:21.086
<v Graham Cluley>Okay. They're doing that, Duck, to Microsoft and Discord. They're trying to get this information taken down and they're trying to grab the information as to who the hacker is as well, because there's an Xbox link.</v>

115
00:14:21.086 --> 00:14:26.826
<v Graham Cluley>I think there's also been some email addresses. There's been setting up of websites as well. The hacker claims, they said, look, 'cause some people online, you can imagine what a fervent community there is who are really into Grand Theft Auto.</v>

116
00:14:26.826 --> 00:14:36.826
<v Paul Ducklin>We're talking about people who spent</v>

117
00:14:36.826 --> 00:14:46.826
<v Paul Ducklin>$3 million in 24 hours to</v>

118
00:14:46.826 --> 00:14:56.826
<v Paul Ducklin>see a virtual strip club?</v>

119
00:14:48.432 --> 00:15:00.676
<v Paul Ducklin>That's without the 27% of the holdings, right, getting boosted.</v>

120
00:15:00.676 --> 00:15:06.706
<v Graham Cluley>So people have been looking at this cryptocurrency. It turns out the hacker hasn't sold any of their cryptocurrency themselves. It appears, although the value of their stash was being pumped up by all these other transactions, they've actually destroyed their entire stake.</v>

121
00:15:06.706 --> 00:15:12.738
<v Graham Cluley>And many people are speculating that they've done this because the heat was rising in the community and maybe from law enforcement as well. And they're sort of worried that, hang on, maybe what I did wasn't quite as cool and groovy as I imagined.</v>

122
00:15:12.738 --> 00:15:18.331
<v Paul Ducklin>Oh, so they're worried that their own fans may turn on them for pump</v>

123
00:15:18.331 --> 00:15:23.923
<v Paul Ducklin>and dump slash rug pulling.</v>

124
00:15:23.923 --> 00:15:31.423
<v Graham Cluley>Oh, exactly. Because the price went up.</v>

125
00:15:31.423 --> 00:15:38.923
<v Graham Cluley>And of course, if they did actually sell their cryptocurrency, such a big chunk of it, the price is gonna go down. These videos, by the way, they all contain the QR code, which will take you to Cyberleek's website where you can go and get the cryptocurrency.</v>

126
00:15:38.923 --> 00:15:46.423
<v Graham Cluley>So they appear to have destroyed — that's their word, at least — their entire stake worth something like $1.4 million of Cyberleek crypto. I mean, frankly, is there anything legitimate which is ever happening with cryptocurrency?</v>

127
00:15:44.894 --> 00:15:51.730
<v Graham Cluley>So the question is, why have they done this? And so, as I said, there's been lots of accusations that the whole Cyberleek thing was some kind of marketing scheme. This was all about boosting the price of the cryptocurrency.</v>

128
00:15:46.423 --> 00:15:53.923
<v Graham Cluley>It does appear that the default is either crime or just some extreme shadiness.</v>

129
00:15:51.730 --> 00:15:58.567
<v Graham Cluley>According to the hacker, they weren't in it for the money. And instead what they said was they were trying to lobby for Rockstar Games to release GTA on a physical disc rather than making it only available via download.</v>

130
00:15:58.567 --> 00:16:06.067
<v Paul Ducklin>It seems that ripping it off before it's released, while it's supposedly vigorously protected online but isn't, is not a good way to convince the company.</v>

131
00:16:02.975 --> 00:16:17.975
<v Paul Ducklin>It is a pun, Graham.</v>

132
00:16:06.067 --> 00:16:13.567
<v Paul Ducklin>Now also put it on a CD where I can take it away and study it infinitely at my leisure.</v>

133
00:16:13.567 --> 00:16:21.067
<v Paul Ducklin>That seems to be more specious than I didn't intend to make money.</v>

134
00:16:17.975 --> 00:16:32.975
<v Paul Ducklin>Whether you approve of it or not.</v>

135
00:16:19.090 --> 00:16:24.705
<v Paul Ducklin>If you've got this thing like it's fallen into your hands, plenty of journalists use leaked data to write stories</v>

136
00:16:21.067 --> 00:16:28.567
<v Paul Ducklin>I mean, okay, apart from the fact that they've done the breach.</v>

137
00:16:24.705 --> 00:16:30.318
<v Paul Ducklin>and then take payment for it.</v>

138
00:16:30.318 --> 00:17:00.318
<v Graham Cluley>Yep.</v>

139
00:16:52.081 --> 00:16:58.865
<v Graham Cluley>I see your point. I mean, the breach, clearly that is quite clear.</v>

140
00:16:58.865 --> 00:17:05.648
<v Graham Cluley>Computer Misuse Act legislation is being broken in order to steal the data, maybe passing it on.</v>

141
00:17:05.648 --> 00:17:10.796
<v Paul Ducklin>But no one knows how it</v>

142
00:17:10.796 --> 00:17:15.942
<v Paul Ducklin>happened yet, right?</v>

143
00:17:15.942 --> 00:17:21.717
<v Graham Cluley>No, no. And inevitably you've got to wonder, I don't think this is the case, but you have to wonder, is this to the benefit of Grand Theft Auto overall because it gives them even more headlines?</v>

144
00:17:21.717 --> 00:17:27.491
<v Graham Cluley>I'm sure they'd want to manage properly their launch, but—</v>

145
00:17:27.491 --> 00:17:37.491
<v Paul Ducklin>We're engrossed in the story now.</v>

146
00:17:37.491 --> 00:17:47.491
<v Paul Ducklin>We don't even play the game.</v>

147
00:17:47.491 --> 00:17:57.491
<v Paul Ducklin>So you've always got to ask that, haven't you?</v>

148
00:17:49.644 --> 00:17:57.814
<v Paul Ducklin>Oh, you think that might be a story they had up their sleeve just in case?</v>

149
00:17:57.814 --> 00:18:03.473
<v Graham Cluley>Another way in which they appear to have tried to monetise the leaks was their website had a contact page which offered paid advertising slots, so you could actually advertise on their website. And you could also request specific clips of gameplay footage.</v>

150
00:18:03.473 --> 00:18:09.134
<v Graham Cluley>They were saying, for instance, if you pay them 400 Monero, for instance, which is a type of cryptocurrency worth about $160,000, you would have, I don't know, images of the submarines or strippers on the submarines or whatever it is that would be your particular niche.</v>

151
00:18:09.134 --> 00:18:19.134
<v Paul Ducklin>I guess that's a bit worrying because there, they're openly offering, we've got this stuff which we know we are not supposed to</v>

152
00:18:19.012 --> 00:18:49.012
<v Unknown Guest>Yes.</v>

153
00:18:19.134 --> 00:18:29.134
<v Paul Ducklin>have 'cause it's covered by copyright. We're offering to sell it to you privately. Advertising on their site, that's one thing, but hey,</v>

154
00:18:29.134 --> 00:18:39.134
<v Paul Ducklin>we'll sell you somebody else's intellectual property is, well, you're going up against Rockstar North, right?</v>

155
00:18:39.101 --> 00:18:45.505
<v Graham Cluley>Normally, if you create yourself an account on one of these sites, they'll ask you for a scan of your passport or your driving licence or something like that. But it does mean that sometimes law enforcement can be successful. They don't necessarily need to break encryption.</v>

156
00:18:45.505 --> 00:18:51.909
<v Graham Cluley>They don't need to necessarily deanonymise a cryptocurrency wallet in order to get information about you. They may just have to go to a company and get your ID.</v>

157
00:18:51.909 --> 00:19:01.909
<v Paul Ducklin>And as we know from recent leaks and busts, there are often things embedded in your data</v>

158
00:19:01.909 --> 00:19:11.909
<v Paul Ducklin>and your traffic, say if you're using a Windows computer, that will reasonably well identify you, even</v>

159
00:19:11.909 --> 00:19:21.909
<v Paul Ducklin>if you're going through 17 different VPNs to try and anonymise yourself.</v>

160
00:19:33.619 --> 00:19:46.587
<v Paul Ducklin>Yes, they've been breached before, haven't they?</v>

161
00:19:46.587 --> 00:20:01.021
<v Graham Cluley>They have.</v>

162
00:20:01.021 --> 00:20:06.741
<v Paul Ducklin>So maybe they actually figure, you know what, how bad was it last time? It's so bad that everyone's been excited about this new game for four years.</v>

163
00:20:06.741 --> 00:20:12.461
<v Paul Ducklin>It's almost as though they can't lose.</v>

164
00:20:12.461 --> 00:20:21.940
<v Graham Cluley>I mean, they've spent so long writing this game. It's been going on for like 13 years or whatever. It's absolutely astonishing.</v>

165
00:20:21.940 --> 00:20:31.940
<v Paul Ducklin>Imagine if you'd spent that long</v>

166
00:20:31.940 --> 00:20:41.940
<v Paul Ducklin>on Jacaranda Jim, Graham.</v>

167
00:20:41.940 --> 00:20:51.940
<v Paul Ducklin>Jacaranda Jim version 42 by now.</v>

168
00:20:46.321 --> 00:20:57.007
<v Paul Ducklin>Yes, they were found unfit to stand trial, I think. Yes.</v>

169
00:20:57.007 --> 00:21:02.493
<v Graham Cluley>So what is clear is that GTA 6 is enormously anticipated by people. It's an enormously valuable piece of intellectual property as well. But it's a company which doesn't seem to really know how people are breaking in.</v>

170
00:21:02.493 --> 00:21:07.980
<v Graham Cluley>I mean, that's actually the most important thing of all, isn't it? What is being done to prevent these hacks from happening and to make sure that it doesn't happen again?</v>

171
00:21:07.980 --> 00:21:13.146
<v Unknown Guest>Graham, what's this about a new report from one</v>

172
00:21:09.327 --> 00:21:39.327
<v Unknown Guest>Right.</v>

173
00:21:13.146 --> 00:21:18.314
<v Unknown Guest>of our sponsors?</v>

174
00:21:18.314 --> 00:21:23.979
<v Graham Cluley>Yes, Black Kite have just put out their first ever European Cyber Risk Report.</v>

175
00:21:23.979 --> 00:21:29.644
<v Graham Cluley>And oh my goodness, they've been looking into ransomware attacks across Europe for the last year and a half or so.</v>

176
00:21:29.644 --> 00:21:35.500
<v Unknown Guest>And let me guess, everything is fine and we have nothing</v>

177
00:21:35.500 --> 00:21:41.357
<v Unknown Guest>to worry about?</v>

178
00:21:41.357 --> 00:21:51.272
<v Graham Cluley>Well, ransomware is up 55% year on year in the first 4</v>

179
00:21:51.272 --> 00:22:01.188
<v Graham Cluley>months of 2026 alone.</v>

180
00:22:01.188 --> 00:22:19.699
<v Unknown Guest>So not fine.</v>

181
00:22:19.699 --> 00:22:25.314
<v Graham Cluley>No, Joe, not fine at all. Nearly 70% of all European ransomware activity is concentrated in just 5 countries.</v>

182
00:22:25.314 --> 00:22:30.928
<v Graham Cluley>And this report from Black Kite breaks down exactly where the attacks are hitting hardest and which hacking groups are responsible.</v>

183
00:22:30.928 --> 00:22:39.203
<v Unknown Guest>So is there anything in there beyond the headline numbers?</v>

184
00:22:39.203 --> 00:22:45.536
<v Graham Cluley>The bit that really struck me is what they found about third-party risks. A lot of companies aren't being attacked directly.</v>

185
00:22:45.536 --> 00:22:51.867
<v Graham Cluley>Instead, they're being caught in the blast radius of an attack on one of their suppliers.</v>

186
00:22:51.867 --> 00:22:57.871
<v Unknown Guest>Right.</v>

187
00:22:57.871 --> 00:23:03.875
<v Unknown Guest>You're only as secure as the weakest link in your supply chain.</v>

188
00:23:03.875 --> 00:23:13.669
<v Graham Cluley>And the report has some real-world examples that illustrate this perfectly. For instance, there's a Swedish company, it has an unpronounceable name. They got hit and that ended up causing huge problems at hundreds of organisations, exposing the data of over a million people.</v>

189
00:23:13.669 --> 00:23:26.172
<v Unknown Guest>All from one incident.</v>

190
00:23:26.172 --> 00:23:35.053
<v Graham Cluley>All from one incident. And the report also covers how regulations like NIS2 and DORA are forcing European businesses to get much more serious about all of this.</v>

191
00:23:35.053 --> 00:24:05.053
<v Unknown Guest>Sounds like essential reading, frankly.</v>

192
00:23:51.709 --> 00:23:59.209
<v Unknown Guest>That's blackkite.com/smashing.</v>

193
00:23:59.209 --> 00:24:06.709
<v Unknown Guest>And thanks to</v>

194
00:24:06.709 --> 00:24:14.209
<v Unknown Guest>Black Kite for</v>

195
00:24:14.143 --> 00:24:24.143
<v Paul Ducklin>Well, I thought</v>

196
00:24:14.209 --> 00:24:21.709
<v Unknown Guest>supporting the show.</v>

197
00:24:24.143 --> 00:24:34.143
<v Paul Ducklin>that I would</v>

198
00:24:29.609 --> 00:24:39.609
<v Graham Cluley>Yes. And so to defend themselves, Cyberleek, the hacker, has said that they've spent about $29,000 setting up their website.</v>

199
00:24:33.696 --> 00:24:38.864
<v Paul Ducklin>Because I suspect that many Smashing Security listeners have probably seen it in the context of the cybersecurity media writing up terrible malware stories. And it seems that we've adopted that word even though it sounds fairly neutral and it's not actually clear what it means. And therefore it can't possibly be clear how you'd know whether you had one of these.</v>

200
00:24:34.143 --> 00:24:44.143
<v Paul Ducklin>talk about residential proxies.</v>

201
00:24:38.864 --> 00:24:44.030
<v Paul Ducklin>And if you did, was it good, bad, or indifferent? And if it was bad, what on earth would you do about it?</v>

202
00:24:39.609 --> 00:24:49.609
<v Graham Cluley>Well, I mean, for goodness' sake, they could have done it more cheap than that, but also the cryptocurrency in the first place. And they said that within a couple of days they made about $50,000 just from the trading fees.</v>

203
00:24:42.814 --> 00:24:52.814
<v Paul Ducklin>Well, I suppose that fits the whole Grand</v>

204
00:24:44.030 --> 00:24:51.944
<v Graham Cluley>Okay, let's get back to basics. So what is a residential proxy?</v>

205
00:24:49.609 --> 00:24:59.609
<v Graham Cluley>So they have been making money.</v>

206
00:24:51.944 --> 00:25:01.944
<v Paul Ducklin>Well, I guess we have to</v>

207
00:24:52.814 --> 00:25:02.814
<v Paul Ducklin>Theft Auto theme, right? You know, lighting cigars</v>

208
00:25:01.944 --> 00:25:11.944
<v Paul Ducklin>start by digging into what do</v>

209
00:25:02.814 --> 00:25:12.814
<v Paul Ducklin>with $1,000 bills. Stuff like that.</v>

210
00:25:09.969 --> 00:25:17.469
<v Paul Ducklin>It's something that does something lawfully on your behalf. Quite a neutral idea.</v>

211
00:25:11.944 --> 00:25:21.944
<v Paul Ducklin>we understand by the word proxy?</v>

212
00:25:17.469 --> 00:25:24.969
<v Paul Ducklin>So in network terms, that term was borrowed as a metaphor to refer to a computer service, like say a web server, that instead of actually being the web server you want to visit, you visit the proxy and you tell the proxy what you want to access. And the proxy goes and fetches the content and gives it back to you.</v>

213
00:25:24.969 --> 00:25:32.469
<v Paul Ducklin>And originally the idea of that was all supposed to be a great idea to have a gateway proxy or a company proxy, because it means that firstly, the company can limit the sites that you go to, if they're legally obliged to protect you from gambling sites or porn sites in work hours by forcing you to use a proxy, it means the proxy can go, no, you can't go there. You can't go there.</v>

214
00:25:31.038 --> 00:25:41.038
<v Paul Ducklin>Also, it can speed things up because if 72 people want to go and look at the</v>

215
00:25:32.469 --> 00:25:39.969
<v Paul Ducklin>Oh, that site's got malware on it. You can't go there.</v>

216
00:25:41.038 --> 00:25:51.038
<v Paul Ducklin>cricket score, wouldn't it be nice if the proxy had already got that and it figured, oh,</v>

217
00:25:51.038 --> 00:26:01.038
<v Paul Ducklin>I'll speed things up, I'll feed it back to the other 71 people.</v>

218
00:25:54.771 --> 00:26:01.808
<v Paul Ducklin>So the idea of having a proxy to do network services was that it was good for performance, good for security, good for bandwidth limiting, and something that companies would routinely do. So obviously you could use it for bad. If you had a proxy that you snuck onto a company network that people didn't know was there, they might go to one search engine and end up being fed results from another.</v>

219
00:26:01.808 --> 00:26:08.845
<v Paul Ducklin>So you can use proxies for bad as well. But in general, as a term, it's neutral. So that leads us to the point, well, what do we mean by a residential proxy?</v>

220
00:26:08.845 --> 00:26:38.845
<v Graham Cluley>Yes.</v>

221
00:26:36.829 --> 00:26:46.230
<v Graham Cluley>Okay.</v>

222
00:26:46.230 --> 00:26:53.327
<v Paul Ducklin>I've set it up for myself on a small server of my own. And the idea is then when I'm on the road, whether I'm out of the country or just in the coffee shop, let's say I want to do something like online banking or I want to pay an electricity bill and I want them to see that I'm coming from my usual location. I can connect securely using SSH back to my home network and then I can go out on the internet.</v>

223
00:26:53.327 --> 00:27:00.425
<v Paul Ducklin>And in fact, in browsers like Firefox and Chromium, you can go in and say, use a proxy, and you can explicitly say, I want to use this particular proxy. So obviously Google and Firefox think it's a good idea to have proxies.</v>

224
00:27:00.425 --> 00:27:10.845
<v Graham Cluley>Yeah.</v>

225
00:27:10.845 --> 00:27:17.057
<v Paul Ducklin>And there's no legal reason why you're not allowed to run one at home. So why has residential proxy become conflated with, oh, terrible malware attack?</v>

226
00:27:17.057 --> 00:27:23.269
<v Paul Ducklin>And that, Graham, is where the story gets both devious and interesting at the same time.</v>

227
00:27:23.011 --> 00:27:53.011
<v Graham Cluley>Yes.</v>

228
00:27:23.269 --> 00:27:28.790
<v Graham Cluley>All right. Okay.</v>

229
00:27:28.790 --> 00:27:34.313
<v Graham Cluley>So explain it.</v>

230
00:27:34.313 --> 00:27:39.529
<v Paul Ducklin>Well, obviously people might want to install a residential proxy like the one I have that they chose to install, where they chose the software and they decide who gets to use it and when it runs and when it doesn't.</v>

231
00:27:39.529 --> 00:27:44.747
<v Paul Ducklin>But what if you could be lured into installing exactly the same sort of software, not on your laptop, where if it goes rogue, your antivirus or your EDR software might detect it and block it.</v>

232
00:27:44.747 --> 00:27:54.027
<v Graham Cluley>Yeah.</v>

233
00:27:48.834 --> 00:27:56.334
<v Paul Ducklin>And the websites they write for take paid ads on those pages. Is it actually fraudulent to say, here's what the game looks like.</v>

234
00:27:54.027 --> 00:28:03.169
<v Paul Ducklin>But on something that you generally don't really think of as a general purpose computer, even though secretly internally it is, like your smart TV or even your home router or a home thermostat or some Internet of Things device that's inside your network.</v>

235
00:27:56.334 --> 00:28:03.834
<v Paul Ducklin>I'm not saying how I got this. I'm not saying I got it illegally.</v>

236
00:28:03.169 --> 00:28:09.679
<v Graham Cluley>And it's not only inside your network, it may also be plugged in permanently.</v>

237
00:28:03.834 --> 00:28:11.334
<v Paul Ducklin>If you like it, pay me a fee. I mean, I don't like the sound of it, but is it actually as devious as selling someone a VPN they don't need that won't work?</v>

238
00:28:09.679 --> 00:28:16.189
<v Graham Cluley>So it may be constantly connected to the internet, whereas your laptop, you know, you shut it, you turn it off, and it can't be abused in that way.</v>

239
00:28:11.334 --> 00:28:18.834
<v Paul Ducklin>Yeah, it's an open question, isn't it?</v>

240
00:28:16.189 --> 00:28:21.727
<v Paul Ducklin>Well, generally, if it's your smart TV, even when it goes into sort of suspend mode, it's still there. And you'd expect it to go online to download updates and security patches and notifications for the TV programs coming up that you're interested in. So you kind of expect your smart TV to be online.</v>

241
00:28:21.727 --> 00:28:27.266
<v Paul Ducklin>And especially if we move away from smart TVs for a moment, the thing that really is on all the time and in theory has all the bandwidth it can possibly have is your home router. The thing that sits between you and the internet.</v>

242
00:28:27.266 --> 00:28:57.266
<v Graham Cluley>Yes.</v>

243
00:28:44.258 --> 00:28:54.141
<v Graham Cluley>No.</v>

244
00:28:54.141 --> 00:29:02.029
<v Paul Ducklin>When they sign up with the ISP, it arrives in the mail and it just says, plug it in. But it is not your router. It belongs to the ISP. You can't modify it.</v>

245
00:29:02.029 --> 00:29:09.917
<v Paul Ducklin>You can't reflash it. You can't run your own software. Even if there were such a thing, you would not be allowed to install an antivirus on it to scan for rogue software. And the one thing you can be sure with your router, it has all the bandwidth at its disposal all the time because that is its job.</v>

246
00:29:09.917 --> 00:29:19.455
<v Graham Cluley>You're absolutely right. They don't want you meddling too much with your router because that's going to create tech support problems for them, isn't it?</v>

247
00:29:19.455 --> 00:29:28.993
<v Graham Cluley>For their customer service department.</v>

248
00:29:28.993 --> 00:29:35.909
<v Paul Ducklin>Yeah. The router that I got from my ISP, untouchable. I understand why. They want to try and make it resilient to things like rogue, unexpected residential proxies and other malware being injected onto it. And they want it to stop you messing with it and authorising access in ways that they don't like.</v>

249
00:29:35.909 --> 00:29:42.825
<v Paul Ducklin>So you're right. Not only is it difficult to meddle with it, the idea is that you cannot. And even if you were to find a way to hack it, it's probably against the terms and conditions of service. And if they find that out, A, they can cut you off, or B, they'll just push out a firmware update and undo all your changes.</v>

250
00:29:42.825 --> 00:29:50.922
<v Graham Cluley>Now, Doug, I can understand why you might want to install a residential proxy on a Raspberry Pi or on a router or something like that, but why would you want to put one on your smart TV?</v>

251
00:29:50.922 --> 00:29:59.019
<v Graham Cluley>If you were a regular homeowner, what would be the thinking behind that?</v>

252
00:29:59.019 --> 00:30:05.292
<v Paul Ducklin>Well, that is the $64 question, isn't it? And there are lots of different answers to that.</v>

253
00:30:05.292 --> 00:30:11.567
<v Paul Ducklin>One is that there is allegedly a legitimate market for these so-called residential proxies where you agree to install this software, maybe in return for free content, maybe in return for some modest discount against some other service. Maybe even in return for money that gets paid to you in some way for installing this on your smart TV.</v>

254
00:30:11.567 --> 00:30:23.463
<v Graham Cluley>Right.</v>

255
00:30:23.463 --> 00:30:32.132
<v Paul Ducklin>And in return, you allow this basically VPN for other people outside your network to borrow your internet connection while you're asleep. But you don't get to choose who those people are, and you don't necessarily know that much about the company you've entered into this agreement with for installing the software. You're getting some nebulous benefit. Oh, you get free games or you get access to some TV channel or other.</v>

256
00:30:32.132 --> 00:30:42.132
<v Graham Cluley>It's a strange world. Anyway, it does seem to me, I'm pretty convinced that the hacker was interested in making some money out</v>

257
00:30:32.132 --> 00:30:37.590
<v Graham Cluley>Yeah, I know some people, not me. I know I'm saying friends of mine, but it really isn't me.</v>

258
00:30:37.590 --> 00:30:43.048
<v Graham Cluley>I know people who have got these dodgy sticks plugged into their TVs, which give them, for instance, access to Premier Football matches or something without paying a subscription. Or maybe it gives them access, I don't know, to some of the streaming services.</v>

259
00:30:42.132 --> 00:30:52.132
<v Graham Cluley>of this cryptocurrency. And certainly they were launching and they were promoting the cryptocurrency before they released any of the images, before they</v>

260
00:30:43.048 --> 00:30:48.884
<v Paul Ducklin>Oh, so it's a USB stick with an app on it and</v>

261
00:30:48.884 --> 00:30:54.719
<v Paul Ducklin>you plug it in.</v>

262
00:30:52.132 --> 00:31:02.132
<v Graham Cluley>started talking about the physical disc, which they wanted Rockstar Games to distribute the game on.</v>

263
00:30:54.719 --> 00:31:04.673
<v Graham Cluley>Yeah.</v>

264
00:31:04.673 --> 00:31:15.240
<v Paul Ducklin>And some of these TVs, they'll come with their own application store. And even Apple's much-vaunted App Store and Google's Google Play, if you have an Android-based smart TV, even they get poisoned by malware, even though they're supposed to have protection on. Right?</v>

265
00:31:15.240 --> 00:31:24.057
<v Unknown Guest>Right.</v>

266
00:31:24.057 --> 00:31:29.511
<v Paul Ducklin>So you get someone offering, oh, well, you don't need to burn this onto a USB stick and then plug it in. Basically, you just install our app and it will provide fun games that your kids can play free, or it's got these fantastic games that your kids can play.</v>

267
00:31:29.511 --> 00:31:34.964
<v Paul Ducklin>It's $3 a month. But if you turn on this super special option that allows us to share your internet connection when you are not using it, unquote, then you won't have to pay the $3 a month, something like that.</v>

268
00:31:34.964 --> 00:31:41.917
<v Graham Cluley>So it could be the case that you're installing an app onto, for instance, a smart TV which has terms and conditions. Maybe this is mentioned in the terms and conditions, maybe it's not. It could be that you are buying from some dodgy website, something to circumvent Netflix or Apple TV in order to give you access to the latest streaming TV shows. And you may be unknowingly opening a residential proxy.</v>

269
00:31:41.917 --> 00:31:48.871
<v Graham Cluley>So who wants to use a residential proxy? I can understand that people may have them, may even not know that they are operating inside their home, but who are the people actually exploiting it and using it? What are they doing with them?</v>

270
00:31:48.871 --> 00:31:58.169
<v Paul Ducklin>Well, if you look at the very many, at least claiming to be legitimate residential proxies, and there are non-dark websites that actually help you choose the best residential proxy provider, you know, top 24 residential proxy services of 2026. And they really do list 24 of them. It's not just clickbait. Well, it is clickbait, but they list all these services. And one of the things that I think that supposedly legitimate companies claim they want to do with this is things like online surveys, web scraping. So they want to maybe look through competitors' websites, and maybe they want to be able to do it from 20 different people in a night and see if they get different results.</v>

271
00:31:58.169 --> 00:32:10.852
<v Graham Cluley>Hmm.</v>

272
00:32:10.852 --> 00:32:17.656
<v Paul Ducklin>Maybe they don't want to get caught out. Maybe they want to see, hey, this competitor of mine, what are their special offers of the day in England, Scotland, Wales, Ireland, Netherlands, Belgium, etc., etc. So there are all sorts of quasi-legitimate reasons why you might just want to buy service from somebody else, right? In the same way that you buy a VPN service.</v>

273
00:32:17.656 --> 00:32:24.461
<v Paul Ducklin>Yes. Which we can come back to in a minute. Yes. Because that's the dodgy side of how you might get one of these.</v>

274
00:32:24.461 --> 00:32:30.528
<v Graham Cluley>Let's talk about that in just a moment. So the parallel which I would draw to this is it's a bit like a botnet.</v>

275
00:32:28.229 --> 00:32:35.795
<v Graham Cluley>One of the things I found funny was on the website where they were saying that you can buy ads and things. They said, look, they're perfectly happy with gambling ads and they're perfectly happy with adult content, but they didn't want any scam ads. So if you were a scammer, you weren't allowed to advertise on their site.</v>

276
00:32:30.528 --> 00:32:36.596
<v Graham Cluley>Where a botnet, which is launching maybe a distributed denial of service attack—</v>

277
00:32:35.795 --> 00:32:43.361
<v Graham Cluley>He's got some standards. I think you'll agree with that. Clearly Rockstar Games aren't happy.</v>

278
00:32:36.596 --> 00:32:43.240
<v Paul Ducklin>You could, if you like, leave the word "a bit" out of that sentence</v>

279
00:32:43.240 --> 00:32:49.884
<v Paul Ducklin>if you really wanted.</v>

280
00:32:43.361 --> 00:32:50.926
<v Graham Cluley>They are asking for information from some internet companies, trying to identify who may be responsible. And also there's the cryptocurrency lead as well. So to set up his cryptocurrency little operation, Cyberleeks had to use a vendor that requested a government-issued ID.</v>

281
00:32:49.884 --> 00:32:55.567
<v Graham Cluley>Yes.</v>

282
00:32:50.926 --> 00:33:20.926
<v Unknown Guest>Hmm.</v>

283
00:32:55.567 --> 00:33:01.250
<v Graham Cluley>It's like a botnet.</v>

284
00:33:01.250 --> 00:33:09.241
<v Paul Ducklin>You could leave the word "like" out of that sentence if</v>

285
00:33:09.241 --> 00:33:17.232
<v Paul Ducklin>you really like.</v>

286
00:33:17.232 --> 00:33:25.587
<v Graham Cluley>It's a botnet because you end up with lots of computers which aren't yours. Whether they be on TVs or routers or fridges or thermostats or who knows what.</v>

287
00:33:25.587 --> 00:33:33.858
<v Paul Ducklin>That somebody else is selling to somebody else who's selling to somebody else to do whatever they want with off your network, with your IP number, from your household, in your name, basically.</v>

288
00:33:33.858 --> 00:33:40.817
<v Graham Cluley>Yes. So this is the thing. It's distributed because normally they would have to do that from their own computers, which would maybe be easy to block or maybe be easy to identify.</v>

289
00:33:40.817 --> 00:33:47.777
<v Graham Cluley>But suddenly this is happening from lots and lots of people's home addresses. Absolutely.</v>

290
00:33:47.777 --> 00:33:54.994
<v Paul Ducklin>And just think how much money you can make in ad click fraud if you are paying somebody else for access to 1,000, 10,000, 100,000.</v>

291
00:33:54.994 --> 00:34:02.213
<v Paul Ducklin>And some of these residential proxy networks apparently number into the millions.</v>

292
00:34:02.213 --> 00:34:16.601
<v Unknown Guest>Wow.</v>

293
00:34:16.601 --> 00:34:26.309
<v Paul Ducklin>Believe it or not, imagine that you can make 1 million ad clicks in a legitimate way from computers all over one particular country, all over the world, that are coming effectively from residential networks. So as far as the person receiving the ad click, it couldn't look more legit.</v>

294
00:34:26.309 --> 00:34:39.541
<v Unknown Guest>Hmm.</v>

295
00:34:39.541 --> 00:34:47.802
<v Paul Ducklin>It's not like 1,000, 10,000, 1 million clicks coming from one massive ISP site. It's not a special private server that they set up yesterday in the cloud. It's basically just, hey, look at this.</v>

296
00:34:47.802 --> 00:34:56.063
<v Paul Ducklin>And you could time the clicks so that they seem legitimate and you could follow them up with visits that look as though the person then clicked through from the ad to further action and all sorts of stuff. And that's before you've actually stolen anything.</v>

297
00:34:56.063 --> 00:35:04.130
<v Graham Cluley>So where do VPNs come into</v>

298
00:35:04.130 --> 00:35:12.195
<v Graham Cluley>all of this?</v>

299
00:35:12.195 --> 00:35:18.536
<v Paul Ducklin>Well, in one famous case, the residential proxy, essentially cybercrime VPN, the one that the provider rented out to cybercriminals around the world, was actually embedded in,</v>

300
00:35:18.536 --> 00:35:24.878
<v Paul Ducklin>irony of ironies, a VPN that they were selling.</v>

301
00:35:24.878 --> 00:35:36.463
<v Unknown Guest>Oh.</v>

302
00:35:31.061 --> 00:35:41.061
<v Graham Cluley>And you have to bear in mind as well that many criminals,</v>

303
00:35:36.463 --> 00:35:42.244
<v Paul Ducklin>So they provided an actual VPN. It was an open source VPN that they'd taken the source code and just modified it. And it had all these super extra cool features. And you paid a fee so they actually earned money and it did actually work. And irony of ironies, if you use this VPN on all of the computers on your home network, all of your traffic, wherever you did, whether you were a crook or not, would appear to come from somewhere else.</v>

304
00:35:41.061 --> 00:35:51.061
<v Graham Cluley>of course, if they're faced with a website which says you have</v>

305
00:35:42.244 --> 00:35:48.027
<v Paul Ducklin>And the only traffic that did come from your home network would be traffic that had come from crooks who'd bought the service the other way around. And from the person who sold you the VPN in the first place, if you don't mind. Put that in your pipe of irony and smoke it. Absolutely crazy.</v>

306
00:35:48.027 --> 00:35:56.266
<v Graham Cluley>Should our listeners be worried about this? I mean, from the legal point of view, if they've got a TV and if they install an app and it happens to have a residential proxy on it, which is used by people to commit ad fraud, it's not the owner of the TV who's committed the ad fraud.</v>

307
00:35:51.061 --> 00:36:01.061
<v Graham Cluley>to confirm your ID, they'll use a stolen or forged ID.</v>

308
00:35:56.266 --> 00:36:04.505
<v Graham Cluley>I guess you could argue that they've somehow abetted the act of ad fraud, for instance? Yes.</v>

309
00:36:04.505 --> 00:36:10.362
<v Paul Ducklin>I'm not a lawyer, Graham, thankfully, so I don't really know the answer to that.</v>

310
00:36:10.362 --> 00:36:16.219
<v Paul Ducklin>And I imagine it would be somewhat hard to prove that the user's intention was to aid and abet cybercriminality.</v>

311
00:36:16.219 --> 00:36:21.541
<v Graham Cluley>But people still have a moral obligation, don't they, to do something? It feels to me as a member of the internet community, we don't want this kind of bad stuff happening.</v>

312
00:36:21.541 --> 00:36:26.862
<v Graham Cluley>And so you should be running a tight ship inside your home.</v>

313
00:36:26.862 --> 00:36:36.481
<v Paul Ducklin>Yes, I think that's perfectly reasonable to say. Try and be a nice person, basically have some ethics. But there is obviously an element of self-serving altruism here. Like you should do it because you don't want other people in your neighbourhood, in your country, on the internet, in your online TV community to get screwed over by people who are using your device to commit crimes. But at the same time, you don't want to be in the firing line on behalf of that crook. Because after all, if somebody is criminal enough to want to sneak a residential proxy into an app you install and then sell it to other people for cybercrime purposes, it would be foolish not to assume that they might want also to spy on you, to stalk you, to do creepy things to you, to steal your cryptocurrency wallets, to monitor your browsing habits, et cetera. So it's almost as though the residential proxy thing is a kind of warning.</v>

314
00:36:36.481 --> 00:36:45.652
<v Graham Cluley>Well, we've got time right now to chat about one of our sponsors this week, Vanta.</v>

315
00:36:45.652 --> 00:36:54.139
<v Unknown Guest>Oh yes, my favorites. What do they do again?</v>

316
00:36:54.139 --> 00:36:59.474
<v Graham Cluley>They stop you running your entire security program out</v>

317
00:36:59.474 --> 00:37:04.807
<v Graham Cluley>of a spreadsheet, Joe.</v>

318
00:37:04.807 --> 00:37:16.768
<v Unknown Guest>That seems aimed at me personally, Graham.</v>

319
00:37:16.768 --> 00:37:23.643
<v Graham Cluley>Well, it is a little bit, yes. But you know how most companies have to prove they're secure to customers or auditors or regulators?</v>

320
00:37:23.643 --> 00:37:30.516
<v Graham Cluley>And the whole thing involves chasing down evidence, filling in questionnaires and forms, updating the same spreadsheet cells over and over again.</v>

321
00:37:30.516 --> 00:37:35.693
<v Unknown Guest>Over and over again.</v>

322
00:37:35.693 --> 00:37:40.871
<v Unknown Guest>It sounds utterly soul-destroying.</v>

323
00:37:40.871 --> 00:37:54.224
<v Paul Ducklin>Yeah.</v>

324
00:37:54.224 --> 00:38:24.224
<v Paul Ducklin>There is that.</v>

325
00:37:54.224 --> 00:38:06.664
<v Graham Cluley>Well, Vanta automates all of that.</v>

326
00:38:06.664 --> 00:38:17.789
<v Unknown Guest>Automates it? How?</v>

327
00:38:17.789 --> 00:38:23.920
<v Graham Cluley>Well, their trust management platform keeps a continuous eye on your systems. It pulls everything into one place and keeps you audit-ready around the clock.</v>

328
00:38:23.920 --> 00:38:30.052
<v Graham Cluley>So no more staring at the ceiling at 2 AM wondering whether you've got the right controls in place or whether one of your suppliers has been breached.</v>

329
00:38:30.052 --> 00:38:44.454
<v Unknown Guest>The stuff of nightmares.</v>

330
00:38:44.454 --> 00:38:53.460
<v Graham Cluley>Yeah, it would be, wouldn't it? But this Vanta solution uses AI as well, and it's the useful kind, flagging risks, collecting evidence, slotting into the tools your team already uses.</v>

331
00:38:53.460 --> 00:39:02.465
<v Graham Cluley>So you move faster, scale without the headaches, and perhaps actually get some sleep. Go to vanta.com/smashing to find out more.</v>

332
00:39:02.465 --> 00:39:12.119
<v Unknown Guest>That's vanta.com/smashing. And thanks to Vanta for supporting the show. And welcome back.</v>

333
00:39:12.119 --> 00:39:17.293
<v Graham Cluley>And you join us at our favourite part of the show, the part of the show that we</v>

334
00:39:13.079 --> 00:39:23.079
<v Graham Cluley>But, you know, hackers screw up. Don't they sometimes, and accidentally reveal their true identities?</v>

335
00:39:17.293 --> 00:39:22.469
<v Graham Cluley>like to call Pick of the Week.</v>

336
00:39:22.469 --> 00:39:29.110
<v Paul Ducklin>Pick of the Week.</v>

337
00:39:23.079 --> 00:39:33.079
<v Graham Cluley>Poor old Rockstar Games. It's sort of put a little bit of a blemish on the announcement which they're making this week with their trailer launch on Netflix.</v>

338
00:39:29.110 --> 00:39:35.750
<v Paul Ducklin>Pick of the Week.</v>

339
00:39:33.079 --> 00:39:43.079
<v Graham Cluley>It's not the first time, of course, they've had trouble with the Grand Theft Auto games.</v>

340
00:39:35.750 --> 00:39:40.893
<v Graham Cluley>Pick of the Week is the part of</v>

341
00:39:40.893 --> 00:39:46.036
<v Graham Cluley>the show where—</v>

342
00:39:46.036 --> 00:39:51.048
<v Paul Ducklin>And that's week with 2 Es,</v>

343
00:39:51.048 --> 00:39:56.061
<v Paul Ducklin>Graham, not W-E-A-K.</v>

344
00:39:56.061 --> 00:40:08.791
<v Graham Cluley>You're right.</v>

345
00:40:08.791 --> 00:40:22.871
<v Paul Ducklin>There you go.</v>

346
00:40:22.871 --> 00:40:32.518
<v Graham Cluley>So part of the show where everyone chooses something they like — could be a funny story, a book that they've read, a TV show, a movie, a record, a podcast, a website, or an app, whatever they wish. Doesn't have to be security related necessarily. Well, my pick of the week this week is not security related. My pick of the week this week is a little website which my darling wife found and she pointed me towards and she said, this is a bit of fun. Why don't you go and have a play with this? It is a website called timeguesser.com. That is timeguesser with 2 Es, one at the end of time, one sort of halfway through guesser, but not just before the other. Anyway, this is a site where you can play a little game. What it will do is it will show you a historic photograph taken at some point in history, one can assume since the invention of the camera, and somewhere in the world.</v>

347
00:40:32.518 --> 00:40:38.211
<v Paul Ducklin>Well, I've got one, the daily challenge.</v>

348
00:40:38.211 --> 00:40:43.905
<v Paul Ducklin>It looks very much like it's somewhere on what used to be the Iron Curtain filled with water.</v>

349
00:40:43.905 --> 00:40:53.076
<v Graham Cluley>Yes, I've done today's one already. So you can change the year and then you can place your pin and hit guess.</v>

350
00:40:53.076 --> 00:41:00.864
<v Unknown Guest>Yeah.</v>

351
00:41:00.864 --> 00:41:06.074
<v Paul Ducklin>And how close do you have to get?</v>

352
00:41:03.097 --> 00:41:13.097
<v Graham Cluley>It is practically at version 42, the number of bug fixes I had to do with that. But yeah, back in 2022, a teenager who was a member of the Lapsus$ hacking group broke into Rockstar Games, leaked 90 videos of Grand Theft Auto 6, obviously an early development version of the game.</v>

353
00:41:03.097 --> 00:41:13.097
<v Graham Cluley>It is, and it's free.</v>

354
00:41:06.074 --> 00:41:11.284
<v Paul Ducklin>I'm going to— okay, so it's—</v>

355
00:41:11.284 --> 00:41:18.847
<v Graham Cluley>Well, you can zoom in on the map if you want.</v>

356
00:41:13.097 --> 00:41:23.097
<v Graham Cluley>He was caught by the cops and they obviously didn't want him to do any hacking while he was on bail. They shoved him into a hotel and said, look, you're not allowed to go on the internet.</v>

357
00:41:13.097 --> 00:41:23.097
<v Graham Cluley>Get the full</v>

358
00:41:18.847 --> 00:41:25.590
<v Paul Ducklin>This is going to be tricky because it's</v>

359
00:41:23.097 --> 00:41:33.097
<v Graham Cluley>It later turned out that he did manage to get on the internet, and even though he didn't have a computer or anything like that, he managed to exploit the Amazon Fire TV stick plugged into the back of a TV in order to get online. In that particular breach, Rockstar claimed that they had lost $5 million to that particular individual, who I think is still being held.</v>

360
00:41:23.097 --> 00:41:33.097
<v Graham Cluley>report at blackkite.com/smashing.</v>

361
00:41:25.590 --> 00:41:32.331
<v Paul Ducklin>going to be—</v>

362
00:41:32.331 --> 00:41:37.909
<v Graham Cluley>It does look like it's in Eastern Europe, doesn't it?</v>

363
00:41:37.909 --> 00:41:43.489
<v Graham Cluley>It looks like it's on a very rainy day.</v>

364
00:41:43.489 --> 00:41:53.119
<v Paul Ducklin>Serbia one way. And is that Slovenia the other way?</v>

365
00:41:53.119 --> 00:41:59.427
<v Graham Cluley>Yes, I think there's a road sign suggesting maybe it's that sort of part of the world.</v>

366
00:41:59.427 --> 00:42:05.737
<v Graham Cluley>This is great radio, by the way.</v>

367
00:42:05.737 --> 00:42:13.213
<v Paul Ducklin>Let's see. And you've got to think of the year as well, Doug.</v>

368
00:42:13.213 --> 00:42:20.690
<v Paul Ducklin>Oh, I have to choose the year.</v>

369
00:42:20.690 --> 00:42:27.971
<v Graham Cluley>You have to choose the year.</v>

370
00:42:27.971 --> 00:42:33.943
<v Paul Ducklin>I'm going to go that it's going to be, and it's black and white, I'm gonna go, it's 19— I'm gonna guess 1964. And then how, where do you, where's the pin?</v>

371
00:42:33.943 --> 00:42:39.916
<v Paul Ducklin>How do I find the pin?</v>

372
00:42:39.916 --> 00:42:49.626
<v Graham Cluley>I think you click. So you've changed the year, then you click with the mouse, I think.</v>

373
00:42:49.626 --> 00:42:58.054
<v Paul Ducklin>Oh, oh no, I put the pin in the wrong place. I didn't get it. I, you can see that I was drawn in.</v>

374
00:42:58.054 --> 00:43:10.398
<v Graham Cluley>You were really in the zone.</v>

375
00:43:10.398 --> 00:43:19.614
<v Paul Ducklin>I was like, I don't want to get this wrong.</v>

376
00:43:19.614 --> 00:43:25.268
<v Graham Cluley>So it will tell you how close you are, both in</v>

377
00:43:25.268 --> 00:43:30.922
<v Graham Cluley>time and in miles.</v>

378
00:43:30.922 --> 00:43:37.621
<v Paul Ducklin>Oh, I was away by quite</v>

379
00:43:37.621 --> 00:43:44.318
<v Paul Ducklin>a long way.</v>

380
00:43:44.318 --> 00:43:55.376
<v Graham Cluley>Were you?</v>

381
00:43:55.376 --> 00:44:00.559
<v Paul Ducklin>Yes. Well, that's irritating.</v>

382
00:43:57.653 --> 00:44:12.653
<v Graham Cluley>Duck, what's your</v>

383
00:44:00.559 --> 00:44:05.740
<v Paul Ducklin>I was only one year off. I said 1965.</v>

384
00:44:05.740 --> 00:44:19.797
<v Graham Cluley>And it was actually 1964, wasn't it?</v>

385
00:44:12.653 --> 00:44:27.653
<v Graham Cluley>story for us this week?</v>

386
00:44:19.797 --> 00:44:26.893
<v Paul Ducklin>Oh, I should have thought of that.</v>

387
00:44:21.818 --> 00:44:51.818
<v Unknown Guest>Okay.</v>

388
00:44:21.818 --> 00:44:51.818
<v Unknown Guest>Okay.</v>

389
00:44:21.818 --> 00:44:51.818
<v Graham Cluley>Okay.</v>

390
00:44:26.893 --> 00:44:33.990
<v Paul Ducklin>It's actually in Zagreb, in what's now Croatia.</v>

391
00:44:33.990 --> 00:44:39.690
<v Graham Cluley>Yeah. So it actually gives you a little bit of text as well, describing the photograph.</v>

392
00:44:39.690 --> 00:44:45.391
<v Graham Cluley>So Duck was looking at a picture of some old cars in the flooded streets of Zagreb, which happened in 1964.</v>

393
00:44:45.391 --> 00:44:56.998
<v Paul Ducklin>So cool.</v>

394
00:44:56.998 --> 00:45:11.998
<v Graham Cluley>I think this</v>

395
00:45:11.998 --> 00:45:26.998
<v Graham Cluley>is a bit of fun.</v>

396
00:45:19.603 --> 00:45:30.277
<v Unknown Guest>Yes.</v>

397
00:45:30.277 --> 00:45:35.815
<v Paul Ducklin>Now there's no such sign because there's a massive freeway, zooming elevated freeway.</v>

398
00:45:35.815 --> 00:45:41.351
<v Paul Ducklin>So boy, how times change, eh?</v>

399
00:45:41.351 --> 00:45:47.027
<v Graham Cluley>So it's called timeguesser. Time, as you'd expect, guess, as you'd expect, and then just an R rather than an ER, dot com.</v>

400
00:45:47.027 --> 00:45:52.702
<v Graham Cluley>And that is my pick of the week. Duck, what's your pick of the week?</v>

401
00:45:52.702 --> 00:45:59.398
<v Paul Ducklin>My pick of the week is a book. It is not about cybersecurity, but it is what you would call a STEM book. It's all about science.</v>

402
00:45:59.398 --> 00:46:06.094
<v Paul Ducklin>And yeah, it was published about 20 years ago, but it's dealing with stuff from ancient history until fairly recently. And it is called Scientific Curiosity, by a chap called Cyril Aydon.</v>

403
00:46:06.094 --> 00:46:17.869
<v Unknown Guest>Okay.</v>

404
00:46:17.869 --> 00:46:24.563
<v Paul Ducklin>A-Y-D-O-N.</v>

405
00:46:24.563 --> 00:46:31.257
<v Paul Ducklin>And it's a lot of little vignettes that take you through how facts that we now take for granted.</v>

406
00:46:24.858 --> 00:46:54.858
<v Graham Cluley>Right.</v>

407
00:46:31.257 --> 00:46:41.197
<v Graham Cluley>Yes.</v>

408
00:46:41.197 --> 00:46:46.536
<v Paul Ducklin>Like, what is the speed of light? How far away is the sun? What is the mass of the sun? How do we know what stars are made of? How did Newton figure out gravity?</v>

409
00:46:46.536 --> 00:46:51.875
<v Paul Ducklin>All of that stuff. Obviously, there are scientists that everybody's heard of. You know, there's Aristotle and there's Eratosthenes, and of course there's Sir Isaac Newton. But there are also lesser-known people like country vicars who just got into science during the Enlightenment, who came up with ideas that were way ahead of their time and were laughed at and then turned out to be correct, particularly on things like dinosaurs and stuff like that.</v>

410
00:46:51.875 --> 00:46:58.393
<v Graham Cluley>So, Duck, you described this book as being a series of vignettes.</v>

411
00:46:58.393 --> 00:47:08.981
<v Paul Ducklin>Yes.</v>

412
00:47:08.981 --> 00:47:15.985
<v Graham Cluley>I love a vignette. And yet it's rather an old-fashioned word. It's like the old-fashioned word for a YouTube Short or an Instagram Reel, isn't it?</v>

413
00:47:15.985 --> 00:47:22.989
<v Graham Cluley>Is this something which you can sort of dip into and enjoy briefly? Is this something which is quite an accessible book with all its little tales?</v>

414
00:47:22.989 --> 00:47:29.237
<v Paul Ducklin>It is. And I will actually read, if I may, from the book itself where the author describes the two ways that you can enjoy it. So it's called, as I said, Scientific Curiosity, but the subtitle is Everything you want to know about science but never had time to ask. And then he has a little essay about what made him curious about science.</v>

415
00:47:29.237 --> 00:47:35.485
<v Paul Ducklin>And it says, this book can be read straight through as an introduction to 2,000 years of scientific discovery, but readers who prefer to treat it as a lucky dip will, I hope, find interest wherever they open it. The book does not assume any prior knowledge of science or of mathematics, and there is only one formula in the book. Can you guess what it is, Graham?</v>

416
00:47:35.485 --> 00:47:44.896
<v Graham Cluley>The most famous formula is E=mc², right?</v>

417
00:47:44.896 --> 00:47:51.112
<v Paul Ducklin>Bingo. You got it in one. Thank goodness. So it does cover that.</v>

418
00:47:51.112 --> 00:47:57.329
<v Paul Ducklin>Obviously that's when you get to the atomic age. Why are nuclear explosions so jolly powerful? And that's that a small amount of mass gets multiplied by a truly enormous — okay, so that's Scientific Curiosity by Cyril Aden. Indeed.</v>

419
00:47:57.329 --> 00:48:04.666
<v Graham Cluley>Is your pick of the week. Well, that just about wraps up the show for this week. Thank you so much, Duck, for coming onto the show.</v>

420
00:48:04.474 --> 00:48:14.474
<v Paul Ducklin>And the answer is loosely, when we say a residential proxy, it's exactly the same technology that happens to be</v>

421
00:48:04.666 --> 00:48:12.005
<v Graham Cluley>I really appreciate it. I'm sure lots of our listeners would love to find out what you're up to and follow you online. What's the best way to do that?</v>

422
00:48:12.005 --> 00:48:23.007
<v Paul Ducklin>I write great content, explain things, do talks, make podcasts and short videos and all of that sort of stuff about cybersecurity. I do cybersecurity for a living.</v>

423
00:48:14.474 --> 00:48:24.474
<v Paul Ducklin>on a home network. And then that leads to the question, why on earth would anyone install one of those?</v>

424
00:48:23.007 --> 00:48:34.010
<v Paul Ducklin>So if you would like to hire me or just see some of the stuff I've done in the past, please find me at pducklin.com/about or go onto your favourite social media site, whether it's Mastodon, Facebook, LinkedIn, and look for Paul Ducklin. You will find me fairly easily.</v>

425
00:48:24.474 --> 00:48:34.474
<v Paul Ducklin>Well, I have what I would call a residential proxy at home.</v>

426
00:48:34.010 --> 00:48:42.045
<v Graham Cluley>Terrific. And of course, you can find me, Graham Cluley, on Bluesky, Mastodon.</v>

427
00:48:42.045 --> 00:48:50.081
<v Graham Cluley>I've even got an Instagram and a TikTok account these days.</v>

428
00:48:50.081 --> 00:49:03.409
<v Paul Ducklin>Oh, Graham.</v>

429
00:49:03.409 --> 00:49:17.791
<v Graham Cluley>I don't know how to use it.</v>

430
00:49:17.791 --> 00:49:24.744
<v Paul Ducklin>Do you do dances and ice bucket challenges and</v>

431
00:49:24.744 --> 00:49:31.697
<v Paul Ducklin>all of that stuff?</v>

432
00:49:31.697 --> 00:49:41.889
<v Unknown Guest>Oh dear.</v>

433
00:49:41.889 --> 00:49:47.210
<v Graham Cluley>Oh dear. And you can follow Smashing Security on Bluesky, Mastodon, or Reddit as well. Don't forget to ensure you never miss another episode. Follow Smashing Security in your favourite podcast app such as Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and Pocket Casts.</v>

434
00:49:47.210 --> 00:49:52.532
<v Graham Cluley>For episode show notes, sponsorship info, guest lists, and the entire back catalogue of 482 episodes, check out smashingsecurity.com. Until next time, cheerio. Bye-bye.</v>

435
00:49:50.768 --> 00:50:05.768
<v Paul Ducklin>And even worse for many</v>

436
00:49:52.356 --> 00:50:02.356
<v Paul Ducklin>You can even see what</v>

437
00:49:52.532 --> 00:50:03.670
<v Paul Ducklin>Bye, folks.</v>

438
00:50:02.356 --> 00:50:12.356
<v Paul Ducklin>it looks like now by</v>

439
00:50:03.670 --> 00:50:03.782
<v Graham Cluley>You've been listening to Smashing Security with me, Graham Cluley, and huge thanks, of course, to Duck for joining us this week, and also to this episode's sponsors, ThreatLocker, BlackKite, and Vanta. And we should also thank those brilliant people who are patrons of the podcast. So enormous thanks to them, including brand new sign-up Paul Davis, the mysterious L. More power to them. Dan H, who's keeping things admirably concise with just a nibble of four characters there. Cheers to Alex Tasker and Sharon and to S.K. Very special thank you to Sabahatin Gukalukoglu. Oh my goodness! A name of such enormous complexity that I am genuinely in awe. And after reading it out, I feel like I really need to lie down. Big love to William Sabados and to Ask Leo, who arrives with their own exclamation mark. And finally for this week, Louis, who is rounding things off with characteristic one-name efficiency. Those are just a few members of Smashing Security Plus, which means they get their episodes ad-free earlier than the general public, and they can have their names pulled out at random to be mocked at the end of the show. If you'd like to join Smashing Security Plus, just head over to smashingsecurity.com/plus for all of the details. And even if you don't do that, you can still do me a favour by leaving a five-star review, liking the podcast, subscribing to it, and tell your friends about it. That really does help. Well, until next week, cheerio, bye bye.</v>

440
00:50:05.768 --> 00:50:20.768
<v Paul Ducklin>people, that home router is not theirs.</v>

441
00:50:12.356 --> 00:50:22.356
<v Paul Ducklin>going into Street View.</v>
